Connect with us

NEWS

Medicaid Work Rules Still Trap Patients a Judge Shielded

Four states sued over Medicaid work requirements that still expose sick enrollees to 80-hour paperwork cuts this January.

Published

on

Four states sued federal health officials on November 5, 2026, over Medicaid work requirements that take effect January 1, 2027. Oregon Attorney General Dan Rayfield filed the case in Eugene, joined by Minnesota, New Mexico, and Washington, and asked a judge to bar federal officials from cutting Medicaid money if the states refuse to run the new rules.

The suit came a week after U.S. District Judge Richard Stearns in Massachusetts threw out an extra test that would have made people with serious illness prove those conditions also stopped them from working. The 80-hour rule itself was not struck, and enrollees whose depression, cancer follow-up, or care for a teenager sits outside a short exemption list still have to feed a reporting system that, in Arkansas and Nebraska, has already dropped people who were working or too sick to finish the forms.

Four States Ask a Judge to Uncouple Medicaid Money From the Work Rules

H.R. 1, the 2025 budget law signed on July 4, 2025, ties federal Medicaid funding to a new screen for expansion adults ages 19 to 64. Those enrollees must document 80 hours a month of work, volunteering, a work program, or half-time school, or earn about $580 a month, equal to 80 hours at the federal minimum wage. Pregnant and postpartum people, parents and caretakers of children 13 or younger, American Indians and Alaska Natives, and people counted as medically frail are supposed to be excused.

Rayfield’s complaint, Oregon v. Oz, names CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz and Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. The states say Congress turned a need-based health program into a work program and then backed it with a funding threat the Supreme Court, in the 2012 Medicaid expansion case, called “a gun to the head.” They want a ruling that the federal government cannot withhold existing Medicaid funds from a state that declines to run the work rules, plus a fast injunction before January.

Oregon’s expansion group covers 564,177 Oregonians in the expansion group, about 16 percent of the state’s adults, and accounts for about $5.1 billion, or 54 percent, of Oregon’s federal Medicaid money this fiscal year. The Oregon Health Authority estimates that up to one-third of those members may lose coverage. Washington’s Apple Health covers about 1.9 million residents, and state officials put possible losses at about 120,000 people. Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison said about 1.2 million Minnesotans rely on Medical Assistance and that the paperwork could knock off hundreds of thousands who remain eligible.

It would be the height of bureaucratic cruelty to rip away someone’s life-saving health care just because of unreasonable paperwork.

Dan Rayfield, Oregon Attorney General, November 5, 2026

Oregon State Sen. David Brock Smith, a Republican, said the filing “seeks to block rules designed to stop fraud and reduce improper payments so that limited Medicaid resources can better serve Oregonians who truly need them.” The states filed the complaint with motions for a preliminary injunction and summary judgment, and asked for an expedited hearing.

KFF’s implementation tracker finds that 44 states, including Washington, D.C., must condition Medicaid eligibility for expansion adults, and for some 1115 waiver groups in Georgia, Tennessee, and Wisconsin, on the work rules starting January 1, 2027. About 19.8 million people were in the expansion group as of June 2025.

A Massachusetts Judge Already Struck the Extra Frailty Test

The November case is the second major round. On June 29, 2026, 24 states and two governors sued over a June 3 CMS interim final rule that narrowed who counts as medically frail. On October 29, Judge Stearns struck CMS’s extra impairment test nationwide and permanently blocked the agency from enforcing it.

Congress had already listed five statutory medical frailty categories. CMS added a second hurdle: the condition also had to “significantly impair” the person’s ability to meet the 80-hour standard. Stearns wrote that CMS “lacked authority to exclude any subset of individuals” inside the five categories, and that enforcing the extra test could drop “otherwise eligible vulnerable individuals relying on Medicaid coverage for continuity of care.”

THE FIVE FRAILTY CATEGORIES IN THE 2025 LAW

  • Blind or disabled: People who meet the Social Security Act disability standard, including blindness.
  • Daily living limits: A physical, intellectual, or developmental disability that limits one or more activities of daily living.
  • Substance use disorder: A qualifying SUD, and participation in an addiction treatment program is also listed as an exemption.
  • Disabling mental disorder: The statute uses that phrase and does not name diagnoses, so states will decide who fits.
  • Serious or complex illness: A serious or complex medical condition, the bucket meant to cover cancer and similar disease.

Stearns left other pieces of the CMS rule in place, including limits on how often a person can self-attest and a 12-month lookback on claims data used to prove frailty. He gave the plaintiff states six months before federal penalties over frailty determinations, a window that runs past January. The work rule’s start date did not move. As of early November, HHS had not said whether it would appeal.

Who the Frailty List Still Leaves Out

A restored frailty definition still leaves a large group of sick and strained people inside the reporting net. The statute’s mental health gate is “disabling” disorder, not any diagnosed condition, so anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress that do not meet a state’s bar will not, on their own, keep coverage. A parent of a 14-year-old is not excused. A person waiting on a Social Security disability decision is not excused by the wait. Gig hours that never hit a wage file, a missed letter, a portal that times out, and a six-month renewal cycle all sit on the same side of the ledger as a missed shift.

Starting January 1, 2027, expansion adults also face eligibility checks every six months instead of every 12, and retroactive coverage drops from three months to one. More reviews mean more chances to miss a form.

MEDICAID AND MENTAL ILLNESS

  • 15 million adults: Medicaid covers about 29 percent of the 52 million nonelderly U.S. adults who live with mental illness, about 15 million people.
  • Share on the rolls: More than one in three nonelderly adults on Medicaid has a mental illness, including 10 percent with serious mental illness.
  • Already working or blocked: In 2023, 92 percent of Medicaid adults who were not on SSI, SSDI, or Medicare were working (64 percent) or were out of work for caregiving, illness or disability, or school.

KFF’s 2023 data show most expansion adults already work or already have a reason the statute treats as an excuse. If Arkansas and Nebraska are a guide, the people who lose coverage are the ones who cannot prove it on the state’s timetable. Rayfield said after the October ruling that Oregonians fighting cancer or living with a disability should keep their focus on their health, not on whether coverage that keeps them alive is about to vanish. The November complaint says taking that coverage away will interrupt treatment for chronic disease, skip screening, and raise medical debt, then leave people less able to work.

Arkansas Lost 18,000 People and No Jobs Materialized

Arkansas was the first state to run an 80-hour Medicaid work rule, starting in June 2018 for adults ages 30 to 49. By April 2019, when a federal judge halted the policy, 18,000 adults had lost coverage. Benjamin Sommers, a Harvard health policy professor, and colleagues surveyed low-income adults in Arkansas and three comparison states and found large coverage losses with no rise in employment. Nearly 97 percent of that Arkansas age group in the survey were already meeting the 80-hour standard or should have been exempt.

“The idea of work requirements is to get people into new jobs and private insurance. But in our study that didn’t happen,” Sommers said.

A two-year follow-up found that most of the 2018 coverage losses reversed after the court order, and that employment still did not increase over 18 months. Among Arkansans 30 to 49 who had lost Medicaid in the prior year, half reported serious problems paying medical debt, more than half delayed care because of cost, and 64 percent delayed taking medications because of cost.

ARKANSAS AFTER THE FIRST WORK RULES

Measure Finding
Adults who lost Medicaid 18,000 by April 2019
Coverage change in the targeted age group 13.2 percentage point drop vs. comparison groups
Employment No significant increase over 18 months
Already meeting the rule or exempt Nearly 97 percent of ages 30 to 49 in the survey
Delayed medications after coverage loss 64 percent
Unsure the policy was in effect More than 70 percent

The 2018 rule used the same 80-hour monthly floor the 2025 law now exports to 44 states. Coverage fell among people who, on the survey, were already working or already qualified for an exemption, which is the pattern the four states say will repeat at a much larger scale if January proceeds on schedule.

Nebraska’s Early Rollout Is Already Dropping People on Paperwork

Nebraska did not wait for January. It began enforcing the federal work rules on May 1, 2026, the first state to do so, for about 70,000 expansion adults. KFF’s early look at the state’s figures, and a review by Georgetown University’s Center for Children and Families, show most of the first losses came from missing files, not from a finding that people were idle.

NEBRASKA’S FIRST MONTHS

  • Start date: May 1, 2026, about eight months ahead of the national deadline, covering about 70,000 expansion adults.
  • New applications: 14 percent denied under the work rules; 86 percent met the hours test, an exclusion, or a short-term hardship exception.
  • Renewals: 7 percent lost coverage; 93 percent met the test or an exclusion.
  • Paperwork share: 92 percent of renewal losses were for missing information; of people renewed for qualifying activities, 97 percent cleared the bar by earning at least $580 in a month.

Georgetown counted at least 1,090 people denied or dropped in the first months. Among those who kept coverage, 61 percent were exempted as parents or as medically frail. Amy Behnke, chief executive of the Health Center Association of Nebraska, said her network usually enrolls about 15 people a month in Medicaid and enrolled none in May, the first month of the new screen. Montana began on July 1, 2026, and Iowa is set for December 1, 2026. Arkansas planned a soft launch on July 1, 2026, without dropping anyone before January 1, 2027.

Lincoln’s early numbers show a monthly proof system, stood up fast, failing people whose hours are real and people whose exemptions are real if the file does not match. Clinics in expansion states are already telling patients to assemble exemption paperwork now, because a lawsuit in Eugene does not freeze notices in the mail.

Hospitals Will See Uninsured Patients Before Congress Moves

The Congressional Budget Office’s earlier analysis of the House-passed work rules, summarized by KFF, estimated 18.5 million people would be subject each year. Work requirements accounted for $326 billion of $911 billion in projected federal Medicaid cuts over 10 years. CBO’s later baseline for the full 2025 law put Medicaid enrollment at 74 million by 2034, compared with 85 million before the law, a 13 percent drop, and put the uninsured increase at 7.5 million people in 2034.

WHERE ESTIMATES DIVERGE

  • CBO coverage loss: 5.2 million fewer adults on federal Medicaid by 2034 from the work rules, and 4.8 million more uninsured.
  • CMS coverage loss: 3.1 million to 3.3 million people over 10 years, with an assumed 29 percent shift into qualifying activities.
  • CMS savings vs. CBO: CMS projected $350.3 billion in federal savings, above CBO’s work-rule figure, a gap Brookings researchers tied to that 29 percent assumption, which they said was more than six times the largest estimate in the research the agency could have used.

People who lose Medicaid do not disappear from clinics. They arrive uninsured in emergency departments and public hospitals, and states pick up a larger share of unpaid hospital care. Rayfield’s complaint warns of that spillover, including interrupted prenatal care and delayed treatment for chronic disease. Rural Oregon counties, the attorney general’s office said, face higher Medicaid use and higher unemployment, which makes the 80-hour showing harder and the coverage loss costlier for local hospitals. Oregon cannot easily walk away from expansion to dodge the rules, because that group is 54 percent of its federal Medicaid funding and already covers 564,177 people.

Sixteen Senators Want a Two-Year Pause Before January

On November 10, 2026, Senators Raphael Warnock of Georgia and Ben Ray Luján of New Mexico led 16 Senate Democrats in calling for a two-year delay of the January 1 start date. That letter does not change the statute. Neither does Oregon v. Oz, until a judge says so.

HOW THE WORK RULES REACHED JANUARY

  1. July 4, 2025: President Trump signs H.R. 1, creating a national Medicaid community engagement rule with a January 1, 2027 deadline.
  2. May 1, 2026: Nebraska becomes the first state to enforce the federal work rules on expansion adults.
  3. June 3, 2026: CMS issues an interim final rule that adds an impairment test to the medical frailty exemption.
  4. June 29, 2026: Massachusetts and a coalition of states sue over that rule.
  5. October 29, 2026: Judge Richard Stearns vacates the extra frailty test nationwide and blocks CMS from enforcing it.
  6. November 5, 2026: Oregon, Minnesota, New Mexico, and Washington file Oregon v. Oz, challenging Congress’s power to tie existing Medicaid funds to the work rules.
  7. January 1, 2027: The 80-hour rule takes effect in the 44 states required to run it, unless a court or Congress moves the date.

Until then, state agencies will keep coding eligibility engines, and enrollees will keep getting notices to document 80 hours or an exemption. Nebraska has already shown what those notices do to people who do not send the right file back. The October frailty ruling removed one extra proof test. The 80-hour reporting system is still scheduled to start on January 1, 2027, in the 44 states that have to run it.

Harry is the editor of REMEDIES HEALTH, an independent health title that he owns and runs, covering fitness, nutrition, food, mental health, public health and home remedies. He has been in journalism for ten years, a reporter before he was an editor, with most of that time on health and science, where the gap between a headline and the study behind it is usually the story. Articles are built from peer-reviewed trials, systematic reviews and meta-analyses, trial registry records, and the guidance published by public health bodies, with each study reported alongside its size, duration, comparator and funding source. Remedies are covered by what the evidence actually shows, including when it shows nothing, and fitness guidance is checked against training research rather than gym folklore. Nutrition numbers are verified against food composition databases before publication. Mistakes are handled under a public corrections policy, and a corrected article carries a note explaining the change. Nothing on the site replaces a clinician; readers with symptoms or on medication should seek proper medical care before changing what they do. Harry answers reader mail at support@remedieshealthfitness.com.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending