NEWS
Three West Clinic Closures Would Send Patients Back to A&E
Betsi Cadwaladr may shut three west urgent primary care centres by 31 March 2027, sending same-day patients back to the board’s worst 12-hour A&E waits.
Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board is consulting on ending urgent primary care centres at three west-side hospitals by 31 March 2027. The clinics in Holyhead, Tremadog and Bangor were built to keep same-day patients out of GP lists and A&E. Mold and Wrexham would keep theirs.
The board cites a time-limited grant and trouble holding staff. The effect, if the west service stops, is that those same-day cases head back to the emergency department that already records the longest 12-hour waits in Wales.
The Board Is Consulting on Three West Sites
Betsi Cadwaladr is the largest health board in Wales. A Welsh Government special-measures report puts it at around 697,000 people and 21,600 staff across the six counties of north Wales, with 96 GP practices and about 20,000 emergency department attendances a month.
Five urgent primary care centres (UPCCs) were set up in the region earlier this decade, staffed by GPs, advanced nurse practitioners and physiotherapists. They see people with urgent problems on the day, by design a relief valve for surgeries and for the three acute hospitals at Bangor, Bodelwyddan and Wrexham.
Only the three western sites are in this consultation. The two in the east are not.
FIVE NORTH WALES URGENT PRIMARY CARE CENTRES
- Holyhead: Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley is in the staff consultation to cease the west service.
- Tremadog: Ysbyty Alltwen is in the same west-service consultation.
- Bangor: The UPCC inside Ysbyty Gwynedd outpatients is in the same consultation.
- Mold: The community hospital centre is not in this consultation.
- Wrexham: The Maelor Hospital centre is not in this consultation.
That split matters because the west is thinner on the ground. Board papers put Gwynedd at 46 people per square kilometre against 353 in Flintshire. Anglesey patients who lose Holyhead do not have a spare major emergency department on the island. Their next stop is Ysbyty Gwynedd.
The Grant That Paid for Them Expires in March
A letter to staff, from Keith Amos, head of service for managed practices in the west, says the original money for the service was “non-recurrent” and runs out at the end of March 2027. Recruitment and retention problems have left the west service more dependent on temporary staff, and the board has struggled to keep a steady rota across the three sites.
Amos wrote that governance processes had approved a formal Organisational Change Process consultation to cease the west UPCC service from 31 March 2027. That is a staff process, not a published public consultation document. Chief executive Carol Shillabeer has described a review of current provision, with the future approach due in the coming months.
Access to urgent and emergency care is a priority for the health board. We are therefore reviewing the current provision of Urgent Primary Care Centres and are engaging with our staff. The outcome of the review and the potential future approach will be developed in the coming months.
Carol Shillabeer, Chief Executive, Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board
The national programme those clinics sit in was never a small pilot. The Six Goals for Urgent and Emergency Care plan launched in April 2022 with £25m a year. By June 2024 it had 16 urgent primary care centres and 25 same-day emergency care services. The west-side money, on the board’s own telling, was still a grant with an end date.
Betsi Already Posts Wales’s Worst 12-Hour Waits
Welsh Government figures for September show 98,700 attendances at emergency departments, or 3,291 a day, the second-highest daily average on record. Across Wales, 63.9% of patients were admitted, transferred or discharged within four hours, against a 95% target. Some 11,616 people waited 12 hours or more, 653 more than in August, a 6.0% rise. The median wait was 2 hours 57 minutes.
Betsi was last on both published board comparisons that month. Only 57.4% seen within four hours left its emergency departments, the worst of any board. Swansea Bay led at 71.3%. On 12-hour waits Betsi was again last, at 17.5% of patients, while Cardiff and Vale had the lowest share at 8.9%.
SEPTEMBER 2026 EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT WAITS
| Measure | Betsi Cadwaladr | Wales | Target |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seen within 4 hours | 57.4% | 63.9% | 95% |
| Waited 12 hours or more | 17.5% of patients | 11,616 people | None |
The special-measures progress report covering February 2023 to February 2026 already called urgent and emergency care “fragile”, with ambulance handover delays and poor flow still dragging on the numbers. About 20,000 people a month attend the board’s emergency departments. That is the queue the west clinics were opened to thin.
What the Closures Would Push Back Onto A&E?
Welsh Government NHS data from June 2024 said urgent primary care centres were then helping about 11,000 people every month, with about 85% cared for away from emergency departments. Same-day emergency care services were seeing about 7,500 people a month, nearly 80% of them sent home the same day.
WHAT THE NATIONAL UPCC PROGRAMME WAS BUILT TO DO
- Same-day work: Centres take urgent primary care cases that do not need a full emergency department.
- GP lists: Referrals from practices were the main route in once the pathfinders matured.
- Stay-away rate: About 85% of UPCC patients were kept out of emergency departments in the 2024 programme figures.
- Scale: Sixteen centres were running across Wales by June 2024, on £25m a year of Six Goals funding.
The board has not published how many people the three west sites see. Nationally, though, the model’s whole point was to stop those patients joining the four-hour and 12-hour counts. Close the west valve and the same presentations reappear at Ysbyty Gwynedd, or they go back onto the 96 GP practices that already handle about 313,000 appointments a month.
In July 2023 the official Welsh Government health account posted from a ministerial visit to the Alltwen centre, spelling out that same design: same-day treatment, spare capacity for GPs, fewer unnecessary A&E attendances.
Today, Health Minister @Eluned_Morgan visited the urgent primary care centre at Ysbyty Alltwen. They treat patients with urgent primary care needs on the same day, creating capacity to support GP surgeries and reducing unnecessary A&E attendances. #BetsiCadwaladr pic.twitter.com/SmPnkXdllT
— Welsh Government Health and Social Care (@WGHealthandCare) July 24, 2023
That is the service now in the west-side consultation, three and a half years later, because the grant was never put on a standing budget line.
The Rural Queue Behind Holyhead and Tremadog
Holyhead’s clinic sits at Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley. Alltwen sits in Tremadog, serving Porthmadog and the Llŷn side of Gwynedd. Both hospitals also run minor injury units at Holyhead and Alltwen, which are a different service. Alltwen’s minor injury unit had already lost overnight cover through 31 March 2026 because of staffing. The UPCC proposal would take another same-day stream out of the same rural hospitals.
North Wales is older than the Welsh average. Board figures put 20.8% of residents in the 65-84 group against 18.8% across Wales. Conservative MS Janet Finch-Saunders, who represents Bangor Conwy Môn, warned that the centres exist precisely for people who cannot get a GP appointment and still need care that day.
These centres help to relieve pressure on our accident and emergency departments when people are unable to get an appointment with their GP but require immediate care. It is vital that Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board supports these centres to remain open. Without them, existing waiting times could increase, potentially leading to delays in treatment.
Janet Finch-Saunders, Member of the Senedd for Bangor Conwy Môn
Holyhead councillor Jeff Evans called the Penrhos Stanley proposal a move with “dire consequences” for people who need to be seen. Plaid Cymru MP Liz Saville Roberts and MS Beca Brown have pressed for clarity on Alltwen. Brown said people in Porthmadog had told her, “time and time again”, they want those services kept close. Llinos Medi, the Plaid MP for Ynys Môn, is among those who have written to the board.
Reform UK’s Helen Jenner, who also sits for Bangor Conwy Môn, used First Minister’s Questions to ask whether Penrhos Stanley itself is next, and to demand that Cabinet Minister for Health and Care Mabon ap Gwynfor use his intervention powers. The clinical case against the clinics has barely surfaced. The argument is about who owns a cut in a board that already cannot clear its emergency department.
Eleven Years of Escalation Met a Final Chance in June
Betsi first entered special measures on 8 June 2015. It came out in November 2020, then went back to level 5, the highest rung, on 27 February 2023 after concerns over vascular care and a damning Audit Wales report. On 27 February 2026 it marked three years at that level. In calendar terms it has been in some form of heightened escalation for 11 years.
Some planned-care waits have shortened. The year 3 report recorded a 66% fall in pathways waiting more than two years since February 2023. In June, about two-thirds of the 3,694 people in Wales still waiting more than two years lived in this board’s area. Referral-to-treatment statistics were paused in November 2025 over a coding error and only restarted in January 2026.
On 30 June, ap Gwynfor told the Senedd this was the board’s “final chance” and that he was “sick and tired” of Betsi as “a byword for dysfunction and declining standards”. He said there would be “no second chances” for people in leadership posts, and that “all options” remained open, including emergency powers to take control. Nine of 12 executive director roles have been filled since February 2023. The board’s own Foundations for the Future programme is scheduled across 2026 and 2027, the same window as the UPCC end date.
HOW BETSI REACHED THIS CONSULTATION
- 8 June 2015: The board first enters special measures.
- November 2020: It leaves special measures after five years.
- Winter 2020-21: The national urgent primary care centre programme begins.
- April 2022: Six Goals launches with £25m a year; the three north-west UPCCs open the same year.
- 27 February 2023: The board returns to level 5 special measures.
- 30 June 2026: The health minister calls it a final chance and puts leadership on notice.
- 31 October 2026: The board confirms a consultation on ending the three west UPCCs by 31 March 2027.
Plaid Cymru took office in May, with ap Gwynfor holding the health brief and First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth already having told the Senedd that Betsi was “on notice”. An independent review commissioned in June was due back in November. Cutting a same-day service that exists to protect A&E, in the rural half of a board under that notice, is the practical test of whether “final chance” changes what gets closed.
Ministers Leave the Call With the Health Board
A Welsh Government spokesperson said decisions on how local NHS services are configured sit with the health board, “which is best placed to assess the needs of its population”, and that any change should follow open engagement with stakeholders. Rhun ap Iorwerth told the Senedd that operational calls remain with the board, while ministers expect transparent engagement and “sustainable and accessible” GP services.
Jenner’s demand that Cardiff overrule the proposal has not been accepted. The health and social care budget for 2026-27 is £12,603m, up £441m, more than 55% of day-to-day revenue spending, with an extra £180m for the NHS written into the final budget. In early November ministers added another £145m for the NHS in a supplementary budget aimed at shorter waits. None of that cash has, on the public record, been earmarked to replace a west-side grant that expires on 31 March 2027.
Finch-Saunders has asked what alternative the board and the government will put in place, how patients will be protected, and what they will do about the vacancies. Shillabeer’s published line does not answer those points. It restates that urgent and emergency care is a priority, while the staff consultation proceeds toward a cease date.
If the west UPCCs stop, Mold and Wrexham still have a same-day clinic and Bangor’s emergency department still has the worst 12-hour waits in the country. The patients who used Holyhead and Alltwen will arrive in that department, or they will join a GP list that the centres were opened to ease. That is the transfer the grant expiry sets in motion, unless the review that Shillabeer says is coming actually keeps the west service open.
Disclaimer: This article is news reporting and analysis of a live service-change consultation, and it is for information only. It is not medical advice, and it is not a guide to where any person should seek care for an urgent or emergency problem. Anyone who needs care should contact their GP, NHS 111, or emergency services as appropriate, and should not rely on this piece to decide treatment or where to attend. Figures, consultation status and proposed dates reflect the health board and Welsh Government sources used here and may change as the review proceeds.
-
NEWS3 months agoPennsylvania Measles Deaths Collide With Falling MMR Coverage
-
NEWS3 months agoFDA Approves XFG COVID Vaccines While the Advice Panel Is Frozen
-
NEWS3 months agoProgranulin and JAK2 Split the Macrophages That Heal
-
FITNESS3 months agoMuscle-Boosting Drugs Near Approval for Children With SMA
-
NEWS3 months agoAlnylam Defends Amvuttra After Wainua’s ATTR-CM Trial Miss
-
MENTAL HEALTH3 months agoAfter the ADHD Invoice, GPs and Waiters Carry the Cost
-
NEWS2 months agoRasonque’s List Price Shifts the Pancreatic Cancer Bill
-
NEWS3 months agoFDA Flagged This Sprout Plant 16 Months Before the Outbreak
